Ask an Expert: View a Question

Ask an Expert is a free question-and-answer service about breast cancer and breast health that is available on weekends. If you'd like to ask a question or comment, please visit us again on Saturday or Sunday. In the meantime, please search the existing topics using the search tool at the top of the page. It's quite possible that one of our many existing topics already addresses your question.

If you would like a consultation with a breast specialist at the Johns Hopkins Avon Foundation Breast Center, call 443-997-8282. It is possible to get an appointment for a second opinion within a few days of contacting us.

We hope you find the information helpful!.

ForumQuestionsAsk a Question
Concerns about Breast Cancer Family History
Questions on genetics, family history & breast cancer.
850 Ask a Question

AskedPublicly Submitted Question
2/21/2018What is the point of denying the BRCA 1-2 test for patientís with adopted and unknown family history?
Selecting lumpectomy vs mastectomy for known cancer in a current patient means the burden of selection is on the patient without adequate diagnostics. If an MD/surgeon had to make this choice would the surgeon suggest bilataeral mastectomies because they donít know the family history?
Seems extreme me. Or would a surgeon suggest that a lumpectomy is a safe option with radiation (for one or two breasts). A negative BRACA 1-2 test means the MD can offer a lumpectomy w/radiation. In the absence of the test the surgeon is transferring the risk factor to the patient for choice without appropriate informed consent. Maybe it is time to rethink this inadequate policy of denial of a medical test.
RepliedJHU's Breast Center Reply
2/22/2018We do genetic testing on women who already have been diagnosed with breast cancer (if they meet certain criteria that would suggest their breast cancer is due to a gene mutation), or with a strong family history. Many women who carry the BRCA gene mutation will opt for bilateral mastectomy. I have not heard of women being "denied" genetic testing, however, some insurance companies may not pay for it.

Please note: This service is not intended to provide primary medical advice concerning specific medical care or treatment. Ask an Expert is a free service operated by health care professionals at the Johns Hopkins Avon Foundation Breast Center. Due to the volume of questions and their complexity, there are times when medical oncologists, surgeons, radiation oncologists or oncology nurses are consulted for their input. These individuals volunteer their time for this service and will respond as soon as they are able. Please do not post or send the same question to us in multiple locations or categories.

The contents of this portion of the website cannot be used as a substitute for a consultation with your doctor or other healthcare provider. It also may not represent the opinions of other Johns Hopkins professionals. It is a free service performed on volunteer time and intended to provide feedback to questions posted by consumers however should not be used as a directive or instructions to now follow. Seeing your own medical provider is always important in getting your needs and questions addressed. In the majority of cases, a clinical examination, review of pathology slides and xrays, along with other medical information is needed to truly provide a consultative service. If you wish to receive a formal consultation with our physicians please call 443-997-8282 for surgical appointments and 410-955-8964 for medical or radiation oncology appts. For breast imaging, call 410-955-4100.


© The Johns Hopkins University, The Johns Hopkins Hospital, and Johns Hopkins Health System, All rights reserved.